About Us

What We’re All About ❤️


Whether you are looking to protect your Florida business, home, vehicle, loved ones, or your finances, the experienced insurance agents at Heart of Florida Insurance are committed to finding our customers the best insurance options available.

Heart of Florida Insurance group serves all of Florida. We have over 10,000 Home and Auto policies that we service throughout the state and we are growing every day!

Heart of Florida Insurance Group philosophy is to write policies that protect the customer with the BEST coverage, a competitive premium, and great claim service should the unlikely event arise!

Heart of Florida Insurance Group

Nathan Bertsch
President

Caesare Sanchez
Chief Operating Officer

Aaliyah Sanchez
Administrative Assistant

Management Team

Tiffany Reum
Manager at Minneola Branch

Jennifer Tenney
Manager at Palm Coast Branch

Malissa Breighner
Manager at Lady Lake Branch

Jomy Barbosa
Commercial Manager

Minneola Branch Staff 

Joan Sinclair
Team Lead & Account Manager

Stephen Castro
Account Manager

Margie Ibarra
Account Manager

Samantha Chavez
Account Manager

Jasmine Estrada
Account Manager

Julissa Sanchez
Front Desk Executive

Palm Coast Branch Staff

Camryn Rudisill
Team Lead & Account Manager

McKala Hosford
Account Manager

Aliyah Garner
Front Desk Executive/CSR

Lady Lake Branch Staff

Crystal Cavallero
Team Lead & Account Manager

Xiomara Lugo
Account Manager

Jessica Howell
Account Manager

Reanna Paolella
Account Manager

Bethany Garner
Front Desk Executive

Locations

 

Minneola Branch

Minneola branch is proud to serve the insurance needs of one of the fastest growing areas in all of Florida. With our great location close to Florida’s Turnpike, you will find that we can meet all of your insurance needs right in your neighborhood.

 
Palm Coast Branch

Palm Coast branch, the professional and friendly staff is committed to providing our clients with access to top insurance carriers and hometown friendly service.

 
 
Lady Lake Branch

Lady Lake branch, the professional and friendly staff is committed to providing our clients with access to top insurance carriers and hometown friendly service.

 
 

Skip to content